| YE SHALL BE CHANGED | No live performance |
| YEA! HEAVY AND A BOTTLE OF BREAD | November 11, 2002 | Madison Square Garden (NYC) |
| YOU AIN'T GOIN' NOWHERE | April 10, 1997 | Sullivan Gym (Portland, ME) |
| YOU ANGEL YOU | January 14, 1990 | Penn State University (State College) |
| YOU CHANGED MY LIFE | No live performance |
| YOU TOOK MY BREATH AWAY | No live performance |
| YOU'RE A BIG GIRL NOW | May 1, 1976 | Reid Greene Coliseum (Hattiesburg) |
| YOU'RE GONNA MAKE ME LONESOME WHEN YOU GO | April 22, 1976 (evening) | Bellevue Biltmore Hotel (Clearwater) |
| YOU'VE BEEN HIDING TOO LONG | April 12, 1963 | Town Hall (New York City) |
| Only known live performance of this song. | ||