| PATHS OF VICTORY | No known live performance | |
| A live performance of this song was often reported for the "lost" Westinghouse TV broadcast Folk Songs (And More Folk Songs); however, a recording of the program surfaced in a video archive, and the song was not included. | ||
| PATTY'S GONE TO LAREDO | No live performance |
| PEGGY DAY | No live performance |
| PERCY'S SONG | October 26, 1963 | Carnegie Hall (New York City) |
| While the song is first reported at the Carnegie Hall concert, it is also likely that Dylan aired the song at his mostly undocumented October 25 concert in Philadelphia, more or less a dress rehearsal for the New York City showcase concert. | ||
| (YE) PLAYBOYS AND PLAYGIRLS | July 27, 1963 | Newport Folk Festival |
| Dylan's only known live performance of this song, a duet with Pete Seeger at an afternoon workshop. | ||
| PLEASE MRS. HENRY | No live performance | |
| Anthony Scaduto apparently reported a performance of this song with The Band at the Rock Of Ages New Year's Eve concert, confusing it with "Don't Ya Tell Henry. | ||
| PLEDGING MY TIME | September 12, 1987 | Autodroma (Modena) |
| POLITICAL WORLD | January 12, 1990 | Toad's Place (New Haven) |
| PO' BOY | November 6, 2001 | Van Ardel Arena (Grand Rapids) |
| POOR BOY BLUES | probably winter 1961-62. | |
| Hajdu reports Dylan added this song to his club repertoire in the months between the recording and release of Bob Dylan. | ||
| POOR HOUSE | No live performance |
| POSITIVELY FOURTH STREET | October 2, 1965 | Symphony Hall (Newark) |
| Probably performed the previous night, at Carnegie Hall, and listed for the uncirculating (if not dubious) recording of that concert. | ||
| PRECIOUS ANGEL | November 1, 1979 | Warfield (San Francisco) |
| PRESSING ON | November 1, 1979 | Warfield (San Francisco) |
| PROPERTY OF JESUS | No live performance |